Are rumen-protected amino acids and choline really effective?
Are rumen-protected amino acids and choline really effective?
There are now many rumen-protected products on the market, such as methionine types, lysine types and choline types. They are quite expensive and the promotional materials are very well written. May I ask Teacher Lu, are the effects of these products really reliable?
--------------------------------------
Rumen-protected products are theoretically effective. The key lies in the process and the amount added, as well as the formula composition.
--------------------------------------
Yes, the amount added also differs at different stages.
--------------------------------------
Effective! But it depends on the diet composition. 2 }3 ]% C9 d4 K' o
At the same time, it depends on whether it is a truly rumen-protected product. 3 c+ L! {5 y; ^* E' p2 r9 o0 f" Z
In fact, there are not many truly acceptable rumen-protected products. Take methionine for example: in the whole world there are actually just a few companies. And the rumen protection technology for lysine is still not very promising.
1 ?. m2 O3 V1 Y) TAt the same time, studies have also shown that although some methionine analogues can produce positive benefits, their mechanism has nothing to do with providing rumen-protected amino acids; their effect is merely to change the rumen fermentation pattern and stimulate the growth of rumen microorganisms.
--------------------------------------
- |; Y% c; f# I& X+ m; H# tWhat the person above said makes sense.
--------------------------------------
It is indeed effective. I have done experiments in this area.
--------------------------------------
Theoretically it is effective; the key is the product quality.
--------------------------------------
It should be effective; experiments in this area have also been done.
--------------------------------------
Rumen-protected amino acids and choline are useful, but whether to use such products or not is related to the structure and thinking of your formula.
) m! W2 V( y/ ^% @4 r. N$ wCost constraints also have a great deal to do with it.
8 v( t% ]* b3 A; A2 `If the formula is well made, the quality will also be very good without adding these things.
--------------------------------------
6# meiyincai
' s- Z! _4 ?" ~; A1 R+ kHave you done experiments in this area? Are the results very good? Could you mention some indicators and the economics of use?
--------------------------------------
Could you list some products? From foreign materials I have seen that Adisseo's Smartamine and Degussa's Mepron are still okay. Is Mepron a coated product? If it is put into production and is economical, it would be better to use fat powder coating.
--------------------------------------
Effective. Resin coating is also good.
--------------------------------------
Rumen-protected products are theoretically effective. The key lies in the process and the amount added, as well as the formula composition.
--------------------------------------
Yes, the amount added also differs at different stages.
--------------------------------------
Effective! But it depends on the diet composition. 2 }3 ]% C9 d4 K' o
At the same time, it depends on whether it is a truly rumen-protected product. 3 c+ L! {5 y; ^* E' p2 r9 o0 f" Z
In fact, there are not many truly acceptable rumen-protected products. Take methionine for example: in the whole world there are actually just a few companies. And the rumen protection technology for lysine is still not very promising.
1 ?. m2 O3 V1 Y) TAt the same time, studies have also shown that although some methionine analogues can produce positive benefits, their mechanism has nothing to do with providing rumen-protected amino acids; their effect is merely to change the rumen fermentation pattern and stimulate the growth of rumen microorganisms.
--------------------------------------
Effective! But it depends on the diet composition./ u) `. K7 Z! a5 k
) j. Z+ ^. q" g0 A, oAt the same time, it depends on whether it is a truly rumen-protected product.
2 s* b{- T3 x& ~2 XIn fact, there are not many truly acceptable rumen-protected products. Take methionine for example: in the whole world there are actually just a few companies. And the rumen protection technology for lysine is still not very promising.
j9 ~* e( d: I8 ^. D1 P. N; AAt the same time, studies have also shown that some methionine ...% a- U$ q/ [8 [6 4 h
awang posted on 2009-3-2 17:54
- |; Y% c; f# I& X+ m; H# tWhat the person above said makes sense.
--------------------------------------
It is indeed effective. I have done experiments in this area.
--------------------------------------
Theoretically it is effective; the key is the product quality.
--------------------------------------
It should be effective; experiments in this area have also been done.
--------------------------------------
Rumen-protected amino acids and choline are useful, but whether to use such products or not is related to the structure and thinking of your formula.
) m! W2 V( y/ ^% @4 r. N$ wCost constraints also have a great deal to do with it.
8 v( t% ]* b3 A; A2 `If the formula is well made, the quality will also be very good without adding these things.
--------------------------------------
6# meiyincai
' s- Z! _4 ?" ~; A1 R+ kHave you done experiments in this area? Are the results very good? Could you mention some indicators and the economics of use?
--------------------------------------
Could you list some products? From foreign materials I have seen that Adisseo's Smartamine and Degussa's Mepron are still okay. Is Mepron a coated product? If it is put into production and is economical, it would be better to use fat powder coating.
--------------------------------------
Effective. Resin coating is also good.